Ministry of Defence
Ministry of Defence

Lest We Forget
British Legion
The Royal British Legion


Researched & Copyright © Martin Edwards 2008

HMHS The Princess of Wales started out as the Midnight Sun. She was refitted as a hospital ship during the Anglo-Boer war, November 1899, and given the patronage of of the Princess of Wales being named after her. Her maiden voyage caused some controversy as can be seen in the article from The Nursing Record & Hospital World (below).

Extract from The Nursing Record & Hospital World 24th March 1900, pages 234-235

Begging the Question

LORD WANTAGE, Chairman of the Red Cross Society, enters into a lengthy defence of the construction, in Monday’s Standard, of the hospital ship Princess of Wales, from which we quote as follows:-

“I think it may be a matter of interest to the public, and especially to those who have generously contributed to the Red Cross Society, and who are doubtless anxious to be assured that their money has been and is continuing to be well spent, to have some account of the work done by the Society since my last report. The uniform approval which has been accorded by the Press to the working of the Army Medical Service in South Africa, including the Red Cross Society, has been so marked that I feel scarcely warranted in claiming space for a few words of explanation on certain points of controversy that have arisen with regard to the Red Cross Hospital Ship which bears the name of the Princess of Wales, and to which her Royal Highness has accorded her special patronage and practical assistance. The condition of the ship has been adversely commented on, and although these criticisms do not emanate from the leading or influential portions of the public Press, yet I am informed that they have excited considerable attention, and caused anxiety and distress, which is likely to increase unless authoritatively contradicted.

On the return of the Princess of Wales from her first voyage, the Central British Red Cross Committee summoned the medical officer in charge. of the ship, Major Morgan, and the master of the vessel, Captain Johnson, before them, and took their evidence as to her condition. Major Morgan expressed himself as absolutely confident of the construction of the vessel, being strong and good and thoroughly seaworthy, and that the electric lighting arrangements, which required some overhauling, are in perfect order. He also stated that there was absolutely no foundation for adverse criticism in connection with the hospital arrangements, which were excellent, that the food was splendid, and that the patients all picked up in a marvellous way on board.

Captain Johnson stated that he never wished to be in a better sea-going vessel. His expression was that she was a ‘sea kindly’ boat, and that she weathered storms when finer, newer, and bigger boats got damaged by them. I can add my own testimony to the above. I visited the ship in company with Major Macpherson, Hon. Secretary of the Central Red Cross Committee, within an hour of her arrival at Southampton, and went over her from top to bottom. I was much struck with the excellence of all the arrangements and the comfort of the fittings, and especially by the perfect sweetness and cleanliness of the wards, pantries and offices generally. The patients, 176 in number, were unanimous in their expressions of satisfaction and appreciation of the good food, excellent medical attendance and nursing, favourable surroundings, and general comfort. The evidence of this could be seen in the wonderful recoveries most of them had made during the voyage. In fact, I consider the ship a model hospital ship, and in every way worthy of the distinguished name she bears. She has been thoroughly overhauled and cleaned, and is about to start on her return journey to the Cape, from whence she will bring home another cargo of sick and wounded men.”

As the NURSING RECORD was the first organ in the Press to call attention to the fact that the hasty transformation of the old boat the Midnight Sun into the Princess of Wales hospital ship did not result in perfection, and as, in the opinion of Lord Wantage, our criticisms “do not emanate from the leading or influential portions of the public press,” it is gratifying to our self-esteem, to learn from this gentleman that “they have excited considerable attention,” and that “the Central British Red Cross Committee summoned the medical officer in charge of the ship, Major Morgan, and the master of the vessel, Captain Johnson, before them, and took their evidence as to her condition,” and, more important still, “that she has been thoroughly overhauled and cleaned,” and “that the electric lighting arrangements which required overhauling, are in perfect order.” And, as this is all we asked for in order to safeguard the lives of our sick soldiers, we remain eminently satisfied with our sphere of influence.

The medical, nursing, and domestic arrangements we never called in question, and in our issue of the 25th of November, commended the ward appointments and arrangements for nursing the sick, so that Lord Wantage’s reference to these details is, superfluous; but as our statements and remarks are “authoritatively contradicted’’ without any reference being made to them in detail, and without, therefore, producing evidence as to their inaccuracy, we will content ourselves with putting the following questions to Lord Wantage, so that he may avail himself of the opportunity of disproving their accuracy, if possible. Flat denials, even when offered in the most lofty official tone, remain unconvincing unless supported by evidence.


1. On what; date did the Princess of Wales hospital ship leave Tilbury Dock-was it, or was it not, the 23rd of November?
2. Was her machinery found to be defective before she got down the river, and was she, or was she not, buoyed off Gravesend for repairs?
3. Did she make a second false start, and was she, or was she not, again taken in harbour for repairs at Sheerness?
4. Did she, or did she not, arrive at Cape Town on the 8th January, 1900, thus taking forty-seven days (six weeks) to make a voyage which can be accomplished in a fortnight?
5. How long did she remain useless at the Cape, and were further repairs found necessary, or not?
6. Was a letter dated “ Princess of Wales, Cape Town, 21st January,” sent to the Isle of Man Examiner, containing the following statement:- “We have been aboard now since November 21st , and in Cape Town for a fortnight, but owing to a number of repairs, which, we understand, will occupy another ten or twelve days, we have been unable to do any hospital work yet. This one trip will probably cost between £15,000 and £20,000. It is a big sum for bringing home 180 odd patients.” And has this statement been proved true, or untrue?
7. Did the Princess of Wales arrive at Southampton on Sunday, 25th of February, with her first contingent of wounded, thus taking ninety-six days, or close on fourteen weeks, to accomplish the voyage to and from the Cape, or not?
8. Does Lord Wantage consider “that those who have generously contributed to the Red Cross Society: and who are, doubtless, anxious to be assured that their money has been, and is continuing, to be, well spent,” are justified in, feeling any degree of satisfaction in paying for the salaries and for the maintenance of the enormous staff of this hospital ship for fourteen weeks, when the work could have been accomplished by an up-to-date steam ship in five weeks?

Now, as Lord Wantage has “authoritatively contradicted” our statements in the public press, all that remains, is for him to disprove them, in his answers to our simple questions. Can he?

Further details appeared in The Mail and Empire, Toronto 3rd November 1899, page 2


Princess of Wales Produces a Big Sum of Money

London, Friday, Nov. 3 - The Princess of Wales has placed at the disposal of the Red Cross Society a considerable sum of money - the balance of a fund collected at the time of the Soudan campaign in 1885 - for the equipment of a hospital ship to be designated by a committe, including Viscountess Wolsely, Lady Wantage, and the Marchioness of Lansdowne. The committe are making arrangements to secure the British steamer Midnight Sun, which will be renamed Princess of Wales. Her Royal Highness will personally contribute £1,000 toward the equipment.

See also Extracts from the Illustrated London News.

Last updated 14 May, 2009

Friends of the War Memorials
War Memorials Trust
Main page
Commonweath War Graves Commission
Commonwealth War Graves Commission

Copyright © 2002-

See our on-line bookstore
Visit our bookstore