Book
Review By Michael D Booker (April 2006)
Blood,
Sweat and Arrogance
The Myths of Churchill’s War
Author: Gordon Corrigan
Publisher: Wiedenfield & Nicholson
www.orionbooks.co.uk
ISBN:
029784623X
First
Published in April 2006
UK Price: £20.00
Gordon
Corrigan certainly leaves no stone unturned when researching
the content for his books. He is like a little terrier who
digs away until he finds what he is looking for and is fearless
when it comes to giving his opinion on any subject. As a result,
he has produced some of the best military history books in
the shops and on library shelves today, that will not only
entertain the reader, but provide a great deal of information
that is sure to be invaluable to the researcher and military
historian alike, enabling them too, to form or revise their
own opinions or pre-conceived ideas.
This
particular volume is no exception and in the same way he overturned
the myths surrounding the Great War in his book “Mud,
Blood and Poppycock”, he now challenges the assumptions
about the Second World War too. In typical “Corrigan”
style, he explains why he believes Churchill was in fact responsible
for the state of our armed forces in 1939 and how his interference
caused a string of disasters, that brought us very close to
losing the war altogether.
Controversy
does not worry Gordon Corrigan in any way, shape or form,
as he goes on to overturn the reputations of many of our famous
generals, including the great General Montgomery himself,
whom he believes owes his reputation to being more skilful
with a pen, than he was as a commander!
By
now, you should have an indication of the style of this brilliant
author who, in my opinion is without a doubt one of our greatest
military historians too. You may not agree with what he has
written, however I can guarantee that you will enjoy this
volume and you too, will want to go on and ask further questions
yourself. |
DVD
Review By Michael D Booker (April 2006)
COMMAND
AND CONTROL ON THE WESTERN FRONT
Author: Gary Sheffield & Dan Todman
Publisher: Tempus Publishing
The Mill
Brimscombe Port
Stroud
Gloucestershire GL5 2QQ
www.tempus-publishing.com
ISBN: 186227083X
UK
Price: £20.00
It
is common knowledge that the command and control structure
of our forces in the Great War has often been the subject
of criticism. This unfortunately has reflected badly on the
reputations of many senior officers of that period and led
to many derogatory the expressions, including the famous “Lions
led by donkeys”.
This
excellent volume, written by two leading military historians,
is a new interpretation of the British command structure in
the Great War and through their thorough and painstaking research,
their findings actually debunk many of the myths surrounding
this unsatisfactory school of thought.
They
examine the complex practicalities of command at that time
and from the new evidence provided, the reader will be able
to judge for themselves, that the commanders facing the criticism
may actually have been a lot more effective than many have
thought and this after all led to the British Army being at
its peak of efficiency in 1918.
This
is very much a specialist volume that goes into great detail.
It will therefore, without a doubt appeal to military historians,
battlefield guides and Great War enthusiasts alike and is
a must for any serious researcher’s bookshelves!
|
|
Book
Review By Michael D Booker (April 2006)
THE
ULTIMATE SACRIFICE
Author: David Turner
Publisher: Melrose Books
St Thomas Place
Ely
Cambridgeshire,
CB7 4GG
www.melrosebooks.com
ISBN:
09548480 – 1- 2
UK
Price: £11.99
This
revealing account of the sinking of the British battleship
HMS Royal Oak, was written by the author in memory of his
late uncle, who sadly died along with 833 fellow officers
and shipmates when the mighty warship was sunk at Scapa Flow,
by the German U-Boat - U47 in October 1939.
The
author has skilfully used recently de-classified documents
that include official statements and reports together with
eye witness accounts that have recently come to light, to
provide the reader with a fascinating and truly remarkable
insight into what actually happened on that fateful Autumn
day.
His
painstaking research has brought to life hard facts, that
include tales of courage, suffering and human sacrifice together
with controversy too, as it is still believed to this day,
that an undercover German spy actually guided the U-Boat through,
what were considered to be impenetrable defences to reach
its target.
This
volume will be an invaluable tool for the researcher who is
keen to learn more about an ancestor who became a casualty
or was involved in one way or another in this dramatic incident.
As it provides detailed accounts of the sinking of the Hood
and Bismark too, it will provide interesting reading for a
wider audience including naval historians and WW2 enthusiasts
alike. |
DVD
Review By Michael D Booker (May 2006)
THE
SOMME
- FROM DEFEAT TO VICTORY
DD Home Entertainment
www.ddhe.co.uk
Retail
Price:
£12.99 for VHS
£14.99 for DVD
Here
is one DVD or video that just about every military historian,
battlefield guide, history teacher and researcher will want
to buy!
To
mark the 90th anniversary of the start of the Somme Offensive,
the BBC have produced an extraordinary new documentary which
puts the entire action in a fresh and new light. This superb
production - a lasting tribute to those who served on one
of the bloodiest days in military history, will be released
on DVD and Video by DD Home Entertainment on the 19th June
– excellent timing for those attending the anniversary
events or visiting the area this summer.
Cynics
may say “what is there, that we don’t know already?”
This excellent production reveals how British tactics changed
over the months of the campaign and turned defeat into victory.
The Somme is usually seen as the darkest hour of the British
Army, when almost 20,000 British soldiers died on the first
day of battle alone, and a further 37,000 were wounded. As
everyone knows, British commanders at the time were accused
of military incompetence, however there was more to the Somme
than just senseless slaughter - it was due to what was learnt
on those blood-soaked fields, that the British Army developed
strategies and tactics and went on to defeat its German enemy.
This
special film features superb and highly authentic dramatic
re-enactments which vividly recreate the experiences of soldiers
on both sides. There is splendid contemporary combat footage
and it compares the assault on Thiepval by a company of the
2nd Salford Pals on July 1st 1916 with an attack on the same
objective by men of the 12th Middlesex in September that same
year. By then, in just a few short months, the horrific lessons
illustrated by the decimation of the 'Salford Pals' had led
to new battlefield innovations - such as advanced air observation,
the 'creeping barrage', tank support and, more importantly,
more power to commanders in the field.
There
is no doubt, that this DVD and Video is a spectacular gripping
account of the true battle of the Somme, it is authentic and
deeply moving too. It is really as offers an entirely fresh
perspective on events, while its dramatisation of real soldiers'
experiences provides a soldier's eye view of the fighting
as never before. As a bonus feature to the actual programme,
there are a further eleven minutes of rare and precious Somme
Battlefield re-enactments originally made for the cinema.
These personalise the War to identifiable acts of bravery;
including the winning of a V.C. for tending the wounded in
'No Man's Land', a messenger's determination to deliver despite
his terrible injuries and always offering a soldier's eye
view of the hardship and danger of war in the trenches.
All
in all, this really is a must buy for your collection at the
suggested Retail Price: £12.99 for VHS and £14.99
for DVD, If you don’t treat yourself to anything else
this month – put your name down for this! |
|
Book
Review By Michael D Booker (April 2006)
VETERANS
The Last Survivors of The Great War
Author: Richard Van Emden & Steve Humphries
Publisher: Pen & Sword Military
Pen & Sword Books Limited
47 Church Street
Barnsley
South Yorkshire S70 2AS
www.pen-and-sword.co.uk
ISBN:
1-84415 319 3
First
Published in 2006
UK
Price: £9.99
Cynics
may well say we have seen enough books published in the past
year or so that are based on interviews with survivors of
The Great War. It is true that there have been many of these
to date and I am sure, that there will be more will come as
we approach the 90th anniversary of the Battle of the Somme
this year, however I can thoroughly recommend this particular
volume as not only does it make fascinating reading, but due
to its handy size and very reasonable price, it is ideal to
take on holiday or when travelling.
Although
I have read the majority of books that fall into this category,
I found this one so interesting and thought provoking, I was
unable to put it down. Besides featuring many excellent black
and white photographs that help put the excellent narrative
into perspective, it is packed to the hilt with true and often
remarkable stories and personal reminiscences that cover every
human emotion possible.
In
common with similar books recently published, a great many
of the survivors featured, have since passed away since, therefore
bringing it home to us all, just how important these volumes
are for both today’s and future generations to come.
This
volume of course covers the tales of those who fought at the
front, it also features the stories of nurses, munitions workers
and those of the children and young women who remained at
home, who lost their fathers, finacees and husbands too.
In
summary, any one with the slightest interest in the Great
War will, I am sure thoroughly enjoy reading this publication
– it’s a must for your library! |
DVD
Review By Michael D Booker (May 2006)
THE
BRITISH GRENADIERS
Author: Henry Hanning
Publisher: Pen & Sword Military
Pen & Sword Books Limited
47 Church Street
Barnsley
South Yorkshire S70 2AS
www.pen-and-sword.co.uk
ISBN: 1844153851
Published
in May 2006
UK Price: £30.00
Of
course, the Guards Regiments of the British Army need little
introduction worldwide due to the major role they play on
ceremonial and state occasions, however few outside the Regiment
will realise that the Grenadier Guards (or the First Regiment
of Foot Guards), are about to celebrate their 350th Anniversary
this year – hence the timely publication of this splendid
volume.
As
the volume has been written by an ex Grenadier Guards officer
and in close association with the Regiment itself, readers
can rest assured that the wealth of information ( not normally
available, or easily accessible to “outsiders”
) contained between the colourful covers is fully detailed
and accurate in every way.
This
excellent publication was honestly a treat to read, as it
was packed to the hilt with a more than generous amount of
fascinating detail written in a very readable style. Coupled
with the wide range of excellent colour and black and white
photographs, detailed time lines, maps and reproductions of
early paintings, I have no doubt that it will be especially
appreciated by both serving and ex Grenadiers, family history
researchers, military historians together with militaria and
medal collectors alike.
In
a nutshell, it is a concise Regimental History, reference
work and photograph album in one beautiful volume, it includes
full details of the Regiment’s battle honours, key personalities,
Victoria Cross winners and Regimental customs, together with
a resume of both its operational and ceremonial roles over
its long and distinguished history.
Anyone
who has had the honour of serving in this fine Regiment or
has any connection with it, will certainly want a copy of
this brilliant title - I for one am proud to have it in my
own collection!
|
|